34
BudDef: Goes better with coffee and not too sweet
doyersthebest: Have you ever eaten one of those home run pies from the corner store? Case closed.
Carwyyyn: pie has lasting satisfaction, cake gets horrible after 3 bites.
The Toaster: The pastry of a Pie is far sturdier than the flesh of a cake, meaning that it won't fall apart for no reason. Also, the neutral taste of a crust balances out the sweetness just so; whereas the icing on a cake is prone to being sickly sweet and spoiling it
pi=ausm: 3.14159265354... is why pie and cake are round!!!
mnolin: Apple pie? Hello! & Ice cream
PIE 3.1415: Pie has better filling shell is much, much better! PIE RULz!
piewins123: Pie has a lot more variety. Also, its eaten on every holiday. Youdont east cake with christmas dinner! That totally owns one of thise dumb cake peoples argument. PIE FTW
kgpayne75: Pie doesn't get stale and it does crumble into inedible crumbs.
TRS MACHINE: Adolf Hitler enjoyed cake, CAKE IS EVIL!!!
Austin: 3.14159265358... is why PIE and CAKE are ROUND
Andreww255: Frosting is TOO sweet pie is just perfect
Beans: I had pie instead of cake at my wedding. There were four different flavors and everyone loved it.
heathersherman: Oh my god. Pie is better because it's classy, timeless, and more versatile. Cake is for ree-rees.
jenjaminfranklin: Evan can we have a pie vs cake taste night at your house so I can finally put this debate to rest? For now, I'm going with pie.
ldoone421: Pie is filled with nutritious fruit and doesn't bother my celiacs as much!
evohollywood: Pie has a more sophisticated texture, relies less on heavy layers of disgusting frosting, and works better with Ice Cream. When people say "a la mode" they are talking about Pie, not Cake. Natch!
19
tyfoidman: Red velvet cake pushes it over the edge.
TPIRman: Pie tries to steal cake's ideas. Boston Creme Pie = CAKE. Screw you pie, you are a PLAGIARIST pastry.
Polar: Pie is awesome but cake is still better.
mindsnack: I vote for cake if it's chocolate!
Zacman: in regard to what TRS MACHINE said: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_law
Yeli: There are more cake quotes than pie quotes "If the people have no bread, let them eat cake!" -Marie Antoinette "I love you like a fat kid loves cake" 50 cent, "For me, the cinema is not a slice of life, but a piece of cake.” A. Hitchcock. 'nuff said ;)
ryan: Cake is much cakier and has the added option of multiple layers of icing.
toast: pie is grooss but cate can kick you pie lovers buts any day but bacon and toast is the best they make the best cuple but ya pie sucks
staciecakes: Cake is the classic dessert. What word comes right after birthday or wedding? CAKE. What did Anne Boleyn famously recommend to end starvation? CAKE. Pie is for people who have nothing to celebrate.
